I know that this is not ecommerce related (at least not for the moment), but since Mobile Payments is the topic du jour, I thought I would comment on it. So, what is it going to be? NFC has been struggling for meaningful deployment for more than a few years and I think the time has passed. Merchants (that matter) have already embraced bar code technology at the POS and if they are not already 2D capabable upgrading to it probably would not be as painful as installing single purpose (credit card network controlled) NFC readers. They can then be in control of their own destiny at their POS and leverage the enhanced bar code technology for other purposes.
Why did NFC fail? When you combine the fact that most large merchants (supermarkets and big boxers) had turned the terminals to the consumer so they could swipe the card themselves combined with the card brands new rules around no signature for under $25 transactions, a lot of the motivation for NFC which was checkout speed evaporated.
The virtual Starbuck's stored value card iPhone app is the best example I have seen of such a deployment. I only wish it was in more street locations. I know it is now in all the Target based Starbucks but Target is not someplace I stop into on my way to work in the morning. However, this is an interesting point as to why the Target locations were deployed so quickly as they already had the 2D bar code technology and a simple software upgrade accomplished the task.
A casual place for anyone who is interested in ecommerce or mcommerce payments to visit and chat.
Saturday, August 14, 2010
Friday, August 6, 2010
Facebook Credits bought by Mobile Payments...Disclosure Needed or Not?
I decided it was time to check out Facebook Credits. Last nite I navigated my way to buying some not because I need any but just to see what the payments experience is. I was curious if they were surcharging their "friends" when paying with a Mobile payment instead of credit card. They are to the tune of roughly 50%. The consumer gets 1/2 the number of Facebook Credits when they pay by charging to their mobile phone number.
I realize that their merchant cost is high due to the carrier's fee and therefore it is not completely unreasonable to do this.
What I do find unreasonable is that there is no clear disclosure of what the deal is.
You have to click back and forth between the choices when wanting to pay with credit card and wanting to pay by Mobile and have to do the math in your head.
When I shop at the supermarket, I expect to be able to look at the labels on the shelves and see that the Coke Zero in the 12 oz bottle costs me $.05/ounce and $.04/ounce in the 20 oz bottle.
It is one thing for some low life elixer company to pull this sort of deception, but another for a company like Facebook that should care about their reputation and credibility. And it should not require the government or some other body to monitor and enforce reasonable and ethical behaviour.
The Mobile Marketing Association guidelines prohibit surcharging the consumer. But, no one is enforcing those. Of course, this reminds me of an earlier post about Visa rules being ignored right under Visa's nose; http://paymenttalk.blogspot.com/2008/05/rules-are-made-to-be-broken.html
What do you think?
BTW, I am going to dispute this transaction. I tried cancelling it afterwards following the instructions in the text by texting back "STOP" and even got a text seemingly confirming that the transaction had been "discontinued", but since the 16 credits I bought did not get taken from my Facebook Credits balance, I am presuming either this is a delayed process or simply does not work. I will call the mobile payments company first and see how they handle it. Then I guess I get to call Facebook and then if all else fails, AT&T. Stay tuned!
I realize that their merchant cost is high due to the carrier's fee and therefore it is not completely unreasonable to do this.
What I do find unreasonable is that there is no clear disclosure of what the deal is.
You have to click back and forth between the choices when wanting to pay with credit card and wanting to pay by Mobile and have to do the math in your head.
When I shop at the supermarket, I expect to be able to look at the labels on the shelves and see that the Coke Zero in the 12 oz bottle costs me $.05/ounce and $.04/ounce in the 20 oz bottle.
It is one thing for some low life elixer company to pull this sort of deception, but another for a company like Facebook that should care about their reputation and credibility. And it should not require the government or some other body to monitor and enforce reasonable and ethical behaviour.
The Mobile Marketing Association guidelines prohibit surcharging the consumer. But, no one is enforcing those. Of course, this reminds me of an earlier post about Visa rules being ignored right under Visa's nose; http://paymenttalk.blogspot.com/2008/05/rules-are-made-to-be-broken.html
What do you think?
BTW, I am going to dispute this transaction. I tried cancelling it afterwards following the instructions in the text by texting back "STOP" and even got a text seemingly confirming that the transaction had been "discontinued", but since the 16 credits I bought did not get taken from my Facebook Credits balance, I am presuming either this is a delayed process or simply does not work. I will call the mobile payments company first and see how they handle it. Then I guess I get to call Facebook and then if all else fails, AT&T. Stay tuned!
Saturday, July 10, 2010
Mobile Payments ... Uuh?
There is a lot of buzz in the "mobile payments" space. But, of course, there is also a lot of BS. But, the issue for this post is simply the issue of the category name. Unfortunately this term has come to be used for such a wide variety of types of payments that it has totally lost its meaning. Just because a credit card processing app happens to sit on an iphone, does that really qualify as some kind of breakthrough? As they would say in S. CA - pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeease!
Of course, if you are out looking for money or free PR, you want to be associated with a hot category. And the pundits just eat it up.
So, I have not written in awhile since I just switched to a Mobile Payments company. ha ha! www.billtomobile.com
Actually, we are doing REAL mobile payments where the charge is placed on the wireless carrier bill, not just using some mobile device as a proxy for a credit/debit card.
Of course, if you are out looking for money or free PR, you want to be associated with a hot category. And the pundits just eat it up.
So, I have not written in awhile since I just switched to a Mobile Payments company. ha ha! www.billtomobile.com
Actually, we are doing REAL mobile payments where the charge is placed on the wireless carrier bill, not just using some mobile device as a proxy for a credit/debit card.
Tuesday, May 25, 2010
Facebook's Rich Valuation Based On E-Payments
Facebook's Rich Valuation Based On E-Payments That May Never Come
http://industry.bnet.com/technology/10008222/is-facebooks-valuation-based-on-e-payments-that-will-never-come/
This is an entertaining article. Anyone who lists Obopay as a leader in this domain is only looking at it from the perspective of having raised a lot of money versus actually accomplishing anything in the market. And, while Amazon is an incredibly successful ecommerce merchant, as a payment platform provider to others, not so much. PayPal, no argument. And as compelling as Facebook is to some, the likelyhood that if neither Google or Amazon can make their payment initiatives meaningful after pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into them, take a guess at my prognosis. There is nothing wrong inherently with Facebook credits, but it is unlikely to rock the payments world. It is just another layer on top of an already complicated and competitive landscape. p.s. As others have found out, the devil is in the details and the devil is expensive in the form of customer service and managing fraud and disputes. Playing around in your social network is entertaining and sometimes productive, but when you touch the user's wallets the rules change.
http://industry.bnet.com/technology/10008222/is-facebooks-valuation-based-on-e-payments-that-will-never-come/
This is an entertaining article. Anyone who lists Obopay as a leader in this domain is only looking at it from the perspective of having raised a lot of money versus actually accomplishing anything in the market. And, while Amazon is an incredibly successful ecommerce merchant, as a payment platform provider to others, not so much. PayPal, no argument. And as compelling as Facebook is to some, the likelyhood that if neither Google or Amazon can make their payment initiatives meaningful after pouring hundreds of millions of dollars into them, take a guess at my prognosis. There is nothing wrong inherently with Facebook credits, but it is unlikely to rock the payments world. It is just another layer on top of an already complicated and competitive landscape. p.s. As others have found out, the devil is in the details and the devil is expensive in the form of customer service and managing fraud and disputes. Playing around in your social network is entertaining and sometimes productive, but when you touch the user's wallets the rules change.
Wednesday, April 21, 2010
Paying with Plastic - pymnts.com
Paying with Plastic - pymnts.com
Just read this free first chapter and based on my knowledge of the payments industry it is one of the best I have read. Great job!
Just read this free first chapter and based on my knowledge of the payments industry it is one of the best I have read. Great job!
Visa paying $2B for payments processor CyberSource
Congrats to CyberSource!!!
I take a great deal of pride from having developed, signed and managed the relationship with Visa 11 years ago in spite of much skepticism both internally and externally!!! Visa invested $1.5m in CyberSource pre-ipo and agreed to the joint product, CyberSource Advanced Fraud Screen Enhanced by Visa. :-) Oh, the stories I could tell you!
I take a great deal of pride from having developed, signed and managed the relationship with Visa 11 years ago in spite of much skepticism both internally and externally!!! Visa invested $1.5m in CyberSource pre-ipo and agreed to the joint product, CyberSource Advanced Fraud Screen Enhanced by Visa. :-) Oh, the stories I could tell you!
Thursday, April 15, 2010
Data Portability in a PCI Crazy World!
I have written previously about service providers such as gateways and payment processors holding their customers data hostage using PCI as the excuse.
There are two new efforts underway to raise the awareness of these inappropriate practices;
portabilitystandard.org
groups.google.com/group/credit-card-data-portability
Please check out these two web pages and join the Google group on the subject.
Welcome your feedback!!!
Note - that the story I wrote about last fall is still not resolved.
There are two new efforts underway to raise the awareness of these inappropriate practices;
portabilitystandard.org
groups.google.com/group/credit-card-data-portability
Please check out these two web pages and join the Google group on the subject.
Welcome your feedback!!!
Note - that the story I wrote about last fall is still not resolved.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)